The origins of odor (β-cyclocitral) under different water nutrient conditions: Algae or submerged plants?

Among the problems caused by water eutrophication, the issue of odor compounds has attracted notable attention. β-Cyclocitral, a widely distributed and versatile odor compound, is commonly derived from both algae and aquatic plants. Planting aquatic plants is a common method of water purification. However, there is limited study on their impact on β-cyclocitral levels in water. Here, we conducted a study on the β-cyclocitral levels in water and the submerged plant leaves under three nutrient levels and six plant density treatments. Our findings revealed the following: (1) Chlorophyll-a (Chla), β-cyclocitral in the water (Wcyc), β-cyclocitral in Potamogeton lucens leaves (Pcyc) and the biomass of the submerged plants increase with rising nutrient concentration, which increased about 83 %, 95 %, 450 %, 320 % from eutrophic treatment to oligotrophic treatment, respectively. (2) In water, β-cyclocitral is influenced not only by algae but also by submerged plants, with primary influencing factors varying across different nutrient levels and plant densities. The main source of β-cyclocitral in water becomes from plants to algae as the water eutrophication and plant density decrease. (3) As submerged plants have the capability to emit β-cyclocitral, the release of β-cyclocitral increases with the density of submerged plants. Hence, when considering planting submerged plants for water purification purposes, it is crucial to carefully manage submerged plant density to mitigate the risk of odor pollution emanating from aquatic plants. This study offers fresh insights into selecting optimal water density for submerged plants and their role in mitigating the release of β-cyclocitral.