Particle-In-Cell Code Comparison for Ion Acceleration: EPOCH and Smilei

Particle-in-Cell (PIC) codes are a popular tool to model laser-plasma interactions. Many different PIC codes already exist, and many new PIC codes are being developed constantly. It is therefore important to compare different PIC codes to ascertain which code is best suited for a particular kind of physical problem. In a paper by Smith et al. (2021) they compared three different codes on a problem relating to proton acceleration in the Target Normal Sheath Acceleration regime from a normal incidence ultra-intense laser pulse. Smith et al. (2021) included in their study the widely used EPOCH code. However, they did not include results from the Smilei code, which is another popular PIC code in the plasma community with a variety of features and physics packages. In the present work, we compare the Smilei code to the EPOCH code for the same test case as Smith et al. (2021). Broadly we find the two codes to be highly consistent with agreement in total ion, electron, and field energy at a percent level or better. The electron and ion energy distribution functions agree well at lower energies and the differences at higher energies (e.g. because of the finite number of macroparticles) are similar to what Smith et al. (2021) saw for other codes. We found that Smilei consumed 25 EPOCH did but the execution time was 30 include the input files to encourage future comparisons.