Specialist training: workplace-based assessments impact on teaching, learning and feedback to support competency-based postgraduate programs

Background Workplace-based assessments (WBAs) are part of a competency-based curriculum where training progression is dependent on the achievement of defined competencies in a real-world clinical environment. There is a significant literature gap on the impact of WBAs implemented in resource constrained countries and their contextual challenges. This study aimed to examine the use, impact, and educational context of WBAs in South African medical specialist training programs drawing on perspectives from both trainees and trainers to identify educational challenges and propose effective solutions. Methods A mixed methods national electronic survey was conducted with specialist medical trainees and supervising trainers from all eight specialist training institutions in South Africa involving 16 specialities. The survey responses were voluntary and anonymous. The survey was closed after seven months when data saturation was achieved. Descriptive statistical analysis was performed using SPSS Version 27 (SPSS Inc, 2012, Chicago, IL) for the quantitative analysis. The thematic coding framework for the qualitative analysis was facilitated by NVivo Version 12 software. Results There were 108 ethnically diverse supervising trainers and 248 specialist trainees’ survey respondents. Across the 16 medical specialities, 45% of the respondents were using WBAs. Despite contextual resource and staff challenges, this study found that WBAs had a positive impact to Kirkpatrick level 2 in providing actionable feedback to improve competency. WBA users had a significantly higher rating for trainee supervision ( p < 0.01), general quality of feedback on trainee competence (< 0.01) and the specialist training program ( p = 0.03) compared to WBA non-users. They also had a higher rating for the assessment of the trainee as a professional ( p < 0.01); scholar ( p < 0.01); communicator ( p < 0.01); collaborator ( p = 0.001) and leader/manager ( p < 0.001) based on the AfriMEDS competency framework. Racism, sexism and favouritism were challenges that negatively affected the training programs. Conclusion Overall, this study reports that the use of WBAs had a substantially favourable impact on teaching, learning, feedback and supports a competency-based approach to specialist training programs. Addressing the contextual concerns that negatively impact training; training the trainees and trainers about their relationship, roles and responsibilities; and focusing on a trainee-centred, inclusive and empowering teaching approach will help further enhance its effectiveness.