Petrochronologic constraints on inverted metamorphism, terrane accretion, thrust stacking, and ductile flow in the Gneiss Dome belt, northern Appalachian orogen

Gneiss domes are an integral element of many orogenic belts and commonly provide tectonic windows into deep crustal levels. Gneiss domes in the New England segment of the Appalachian orogen have been classically associated with diapirism and fold interference, but alternative models involving ductile flow have been proposed. We evaluate these models in the Gneiss Dome belt of western New England with U-Th-Pb monazite, xenotime, zircon, and titanite petrochronology and major and trace element thermobarometry. These data constrain distinct pressure-temperature-time (P-T-t) paths for each unit in the gneiss dome belt tectono-stratigraphy. The structurally lowest units, Laurentia-derived migmatitic gneisses of the Waterbury dome, document two stages of metamorphism (455-435 and 400-370 Ma) with peak Acadian metamorphic conditions of similar to 1.0-1.2 GPa at 750-780 degrees C at 391 +/- 7 to 386 +/- 4 Ma. The next structurally higher unit, the Gondwana-derived Taine Mountain Formation, records Taconic (peak conditions: 0.6 GPa, 600 degrees C at 441 +/- 4 Ma) and Acadian (peak: 0.8-1.0 GPa, 650 degrees C at 377 +/- 4 Ma) metamorphism. The overlying Collinsville Formation yielded a 473 +/- 5 Ma crystallization age and evidence for metamorphic conditions of 650 degrees C at 436 +/- 4 Ma and 1.2-1.0 GPa, 750-775 degrees C at 397 +/- 4 to 385 +/- 6 Ma. The structurally higher Sweetheart Mountain Member of the Collinsville Formation yielded only Acadian zircon, monazite, and xenotime dates and evidence for high-pressure granulite facies metamorphism (1.8 GPa, 815 degrees C) at circa 380-375 Ma. Cover rocks of the dome-mantling The Straits Schist records peak conditions of similar to 1 GPa, 700 degrees C at 386 +/- 6 to 380 +/- 4 Ma. Garnet breakdown to monazite and/or xenotime occurred in all units at circa 375-360 and 345-330 Ma. Peak Acadian metamorphic pressures increase systematically from the structurally lowest to highest units (from 1.0 to 1.8 GPa). This inverted metamorphic sequence is incompatible with the diapiric and fold interference models, which predict the highest pressures at the structurally lowest levels. Based upon P-T-t and structural data, we prefer a model involving, first, circa 380 Ma thrust stacking followed by syn-collisional orogen parallel extension, ductile flow, and rise of the domes between 380 and 365 Ma. Garnet breakdown at circa 345-330 Ma is interpreted to reflect further exhumation during collapse of the Acadian orogenic plateau. These results highlight the power of integrating petrologic constraints with paired geochemical and geochronologic data from multiple chronometers to test structural and tectonic models and show that syn-convergent orogen parallel ductile flow dramatically modified earlier accretion-related structures in New England. Further, the Gneiss Dome belt documents gneiss dome development in a syn-collisional, thick crust setting, providing an ancient example of middle to lower crustal processes that may be occurring today in the modern Himalaya and Pamir Range.