Prioritized Robotic Exploration with Deadlines: A Comparison of Greedy, Orienteering, and Profitable Tour Approaches

This paper addresses the problem of robotic exploration of unknown indoor environments with deadlines. Indoor exploration using mobile robots has typically focused on exploring the entire environment without considering deadlines. The objective of the prioritized exploration in this paper is to rapidly compute the geometric layout of an initially unknown environment by exploring key regions of the environment and returning to the home location within a deadline. This prioritized exploration is useful for time-critical and dangerous environments where rapid robot exploration can provide vital information for subsequent operations. For example, firefighters, for whom time is of the essence, can utilize the map generated by this robotic exploration to navigate a building on fire. In our previous work, we showed that a priority-based greedy algorithm can outperform a cost-based greedy algorithm for exploration under deadlines. This paper models the prioritized exploration problem as an Orienteering Problem (OP) and a Profitable Tour Problem (PTP) in an attempt to generate exploration strategies that can explore a greater percentage of the environment in a given amount of time. The paper presents simulation results on multiple graph-based and Gazebo environments. We found that in many cases the priority-based greedy algorithm performs on par or better than the OP and PTP-based algorithms. We analyze the potential reasons for this counterintuitive result.