Comparison Of Baseline Patient Characteristics In Immunotherapy Versus Targeted Therapy Trials For Advanced Melanoma.

e22012 Background: Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI) or BRAF/MEK targeted therapy are both FDA approved first line options for BRAF mutant advanced melanoma. However, the optimal sequencing of these approaches and the profile of patients who benefit the most from one treatment over the other is suboptimally defined. Methods: We compared the baseline characteristics of the participants enrolled in the immunotherapy (IT) and targeted therapy (TT) trials quoted in the NCCN guidelines as the guidelines are used by many oncologists who do not subspecialize in melanoma to formulate treatment plans. Data was gathered about age, sex, race, ECOG score, LDH levels, stage, BRAF mutation status, PD-L1 expression and prior lines of therapy. Results: Median age range was younger in the TT population (48-57 y) as compared to the IT population (56-65 y); > 50% were males. 54-82% patients in the IT trials had an ECOG score of 0. Relatively more patients (pts) with ECOG score of 1 were included in Dabrafenib/ Trametinib and Vemurafenib/Cobimetinib trials (62-65%). Most pts had stage IV M1c disease. LDH levels were similar in IT and TT trials. V600E mutation was uniformly more common in the TT trials as expected. PD-L1 expression varied widely; from 23% to 81% patients with a high PD-L1 expression. Trials evaluating pembrolizumab included patients (7-26%) who were previously treated with BRAF/MEK inhibitor, however TT trials did not include as many pts exposed to ICI. Conclusions: Age range and sex ratio of the pts included in the trials were representative of the epidemiology of melanoma, but race was underreported. TT studies trended towards a younger median age range than patients treated in the IT studies. However optimal biomarkers for initial treatment choice cannot be determined by the patient demographics and characteristics presented in the studies discussed in the NCCN guidelines. Studies randomizing treatment sequence and identification of biomarkers prognostic of patient specific treatment efficacy are needed. Comparison of the IT and TT studies support the choice of either approach as initial treatment in pts with BRAF mutant melanoma lacking contraindications.