Trunnionosis and adverse reaction to metal debris in uncemented metal-on-polyethylene trident-accolade total hip replacements: a case series and review of recent literature

Adverse reaction to metal debris (ARMD) is well recognised as a complication of large head metal on metal total hip replacement (THR) leading to pain, bone and tissue loss and the need for revision surgery. An emerging problem of trunnionosis in metal on polyethylene total hip replacements leading to ARMD has been reported in a few cases. Increased metal ion levels have been reported in THR9s with a titanium stem and a cobalt chrome head such as the Accolade-Trident THR (Stryker). We present 3 cases of ARMD with Accloade-Trident THR9s with 36mm cobalt chrome head and a polyethylene liner. Metal ion levels were elevated in all three patients (cobalt 10.3 – 161nmol/l). Intraoperative tissue samples were negative for infection and inflammatory markers were normal. Abnormal fluid collections were seen in all three cases and bone loss was severe in one patient leading to a proximal femoral replacement. Histology demonstrated either a non-specific inflammatory reaction in a case which presented early or a granulomatous reaction in a more advanced case suggesting a local foreign body reaction. All patients had improved symptoms post-operatively. 1 patient who had staged bilateral Accolade-Trident THR9s required revision of both THR9s. ARMD in metal on polyethylene THR9s with a titanium stem represents a potential emerging problem. Further studies are required to assess whether these occurrences are rare or represent the tip of an iceberg.