Asymmetry of hemispheric climate during MIS 16 versus MIS 12

Marine isotope stage (MIS) 16 (676-621 ka) and MIS 12 (478-424 ka) stand out as two significant glacial periods during the late Quaternary, demonstrating consistent continental ice volume or sea level, as discerned from benthic δ18O records. Intriguingly, the average sea surface temperature (SST) during MIS 16 surpasses that of MIS 12 by approximately 0.54–0.79 °C, while the atmospheric CO2 concentration during MIS 16 is approximately 16 ppmv lower than that of MIS 12. The underlying mechanism driving these discrepancies remains enigmatic. In this study, we present new high-resolution X-ray fluorescence (XRF) and grain size records covering the interval from 700 to 400 ka from Ocean Drilling Program (ODP) Site 1090 in the South Atlantic Ocean. We also integrated benthic δ13C, ice-rafted debris (IRD) and carbonate ion concentration ([CO32−]) records globally, to elucidate the distinct climate evolution during the MIS 16 versus MIS 12. Our findings suggest that MIS 12 is distinguished by a more substantial Antarctic ice-sheet, coupled with a weakened and/or equatorward displacement of southern westerly winds, and expansion of southern source water (SSW) alongside contractive northern source water (NSW). Conversely, the opposite climate state can be observed in MIS 16. The elevated atmospheric CO2 in MIS 12 and diminished atmospheric CO2 in MIS 16 may be attributed to reconfigurations in the ocean carbon reservoir regulated by the reorganization of deep-water masses and meridional ocean circulation, as a result of the divergent evolution of bipolar ice-sheets. Our study underscores the critical role of the interplay between the two polar regions in modulating deep-sea carbon storage on the orbital timescale and atmospheric CO2. This interplay is essential for a comprehensive understanding of past and future carbon cycle adjustments in response to climate change.