Exaggerated Plurivory of Macrophomina phaseolina: Accounting for the Large Host Range Claim and the Shifting of Scientific Language

Macrophomina phaseolina is a plant pathogenic fungus that is frequently described as having a broad host range encompassing more than 500 species. We noticed that citations provided in support of this statement do not actually demonstrate such a broad host range. To elucidate the true documented host range of this fungus, we initiated a literature meta-analysis of 894 publications on M. phaseolina since 1913. We discovered that the first host range summaries did not require Koch's postulates or other experimental demonstrations of pathogenicity. Most of the available early host claims were based on tenuous associations between the fungus and symptoms, sometimes without reporting isolation or morphological examination in vitro. These statements apparently led to a pattern of increasingly exaggerated host range claims, without support from a primary reference, until the claim that M. phaseolina has 500 hosts became common in the early 2000s. At present, the scientific community typically requires Koch's postulates to characterize pathogenicity on a new host. Among all the available literature, we only found primary experimental evidence for M. phaseolina's pathogenicity on 97 hosts; 74 hosts confirmed by Koch's postulates and 23 hosts with all steps from Koch's postulates completed except for recovery of the pathogen from symptomatic tissues. This study demonstrates how scientific concepts can change over time and necessitate changes to historic axioms. We propose that the hyperbole surrounding the host range of M. phaseolina has obscured an accurate depiction of its biology.