Emerging resilience metrics in an intensely managed ecological system

There is growing interest in understanding resilience of ecosystems because of the potential of abrupt and possibly irreversible shifts between alternative ecosystem states. Tipping points are observed in systems with strong positive feedback, providing early warning signals of potential instability. These points can be detected through metrics like critical slowing down (CSD), such as increased recovery time, variance, and autocorrelation. These indicators have been tested in laboratory experiments and field settings, ignoring trait changes. Here we present a long-term temporal analysis of several large, intensely monitored constructed wetlands, the Everglades Stormwater Treatment Areas (STAs), in which sudden changes in plant community composition have been observed. Using wavelet analysis, significant increases and decreases of variance properties (long-term flow data, water quality and nutrient TP loads) across these systems can indicate when and which STAs are less resilient to perturbations. In this study, continuous wavelet transform (CWT) was used to determine the periodicity of any cyclical activity in the data and to determine changes in autocorrelation and variance as measures of CSD. The change detection methods were used to find significant changes in variations and correlations across the time series. By employing these techniques, we were able to spot substantial shifts in model-observed wavelet correlation and model residual wavelet variance and thereby identify where these systems exhibit CSD. Although our analysis is limited to historical data, the proposed approach has practical value in that it identifies STAs that may be vulnerable to perturbation. The study also presents one of the few studies in which CSD is observed in practice rather than modelled in theory.