Effects of wound irrigation solutions on host tissue: murine air pouch infection model

Irrigation with antiseptic agents, antibiotics, and surfactants are used for treatment and prevention of infections. Despite desirable microbicidal actions, studies have demonstrated cytotoxic effects on host tissue that may impair healing. This study investigated the extent of tissue damage caused by commonly used irrigation solutions in the presence or absence of infection. Air pouches created in 60 balb/c mice were divided into two groups (n=30): infected with Staphylococcus aureus and control. One week later the infected group was subdivided into 5 subgroups (n=6) based on irrigation solutions and by day 0 (immediately) and day7 after irrigation (n=3). Solutions included Saline, Bacitracin, Clorpactin, Irrisept and Bactisure. In infected group wash fluid was collected for quantitative analysis of bacterial growth. At the specified times mice were sacrificed, pouch tissue sent for histology, and sections analyzed for inflammation, necrosis, and edema. Inflammation decreased in infected vs sterile pouches for all solutions except Bacitracin day 0 and for all solutions day 7 with significance in all except Bacitracin (p<0.05). On day 0, necrosis increased in infected vs sterile pouches in Bacitracin (p=0.006), Irrisept (p=0.18), or Bactisure (p=0.07); however, on day 7, necrosis significantly decreased in infected pouches for all solutions (p<0.05) except for Clorpactin (p=0.18). Edema decreased in infected vs sterile pouches on day 0 for all solutions with significance in saline, Irrisept, and Bacitracin (p<0.05). On day 7, infected pouches had decreased edema in saline, Bacitracin, and Bactisure (p<0.05) and increased in Irrisept (p<0.05) and Clorpactin (p=0.069) compared to sterile pouches. Bacterial culture of washouts demonstrated that Clorpactin, Irrisept and Bactisure controlled the infection, whereas saline and Bacitracin showed bacterial multiplication 3.9 × 10^7 CFU/ml and 6.7 × 10^7 CFU/ml respectively. Bacitracin wash showed significantly more bacteria growth compared to Clorpactin (p=0.024), Irrisept (p=0.025) and Bactisure (p=0.025). Tissue damage varied with irrigation solutions and the presence or absence of infection. Presence of bacteria appeared to lead to less tissue inflammation and edema. Tissue necrosis varied over time with different solutions. Surgeons must weigh risks and benefits when selecting solutions and determining when to irrigate.