Needle Arthroscopy as a Promising Alternative to MRI for the Diagnosis of Meniscus Injury

Meniscal injury is a common cause of knee pain and functional impairment, often necessitating surgical intervention. Although magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is frequently used for diagnosis, its accuracy is variable and may lead to false positives and negatives. To address these issues, needle arthroscopy has gained attention as a potential diagnostic alternative to MRI because of its immediate availability and ability to directly visualize intra-articular structures. This study aimed to assess the diagnostic capabilities of needle arthroscopy in comparison with MRI and diagnostic arthroscopy for meniscal injuries. Forty patients with suspected meniscal injuries requiring surgical treatment were enrolled between November 2017 and March 2019. A needle arthroscope with a 0.95-mm diameter was used to evaluate meniscal injuries. Three orthopaedic surgeons with approximately 10 years of experience independently evaluated the images from the needle arthroscopy, diagnostic arthroscopy, and preoperative MRI without any knowledge regarding patients' information. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) of each modality were used to compare the diagnostic accuracies. For lateral meniscus (LM) injuries, the sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV of needle arthroscopy compared to diagnostic arthroscopy were 0.706, 0.852, 0.148, and 0.294, respectively. For medial meniscus (MM) injuries, the corresponding values were 0.889, 0.864, 0.136, and 0.111, respectively. In comparison, MRI had a lower sensitivity for LM injuries (0.588) and a higher sensitivity for MM injuries (1.0). The agreement between diagnostic arthroscopy and needle arthroscopy was moderate (kappa=0.517), while the agreements between diagnostic arthroscopy or needle arthroscopy and MRI were poor. Similar patterns were observed for the presence, location, and tear patterns of meniscal injuries. In conclusion, needle arthroscopy shows promise as an effective diagnostic modality for meniscal injuries, surpassing the limitations of MRI.