Time-based vs. Fingerprinting-based Positioning Using Artificial Neural Networks

High-accuracy positioning has gained significant interest for many use-cases across various domains such as industrial internet of things (IIoT), healthcare and entertainment. Radio frequency (RF) measurements are widely utilized for user localization. However, challenging radio conditions such as non-line-of-sight (NLOS) and multipath propagation can deteriorate the positioning accuracy. Machine learning (ML)-based estimators have been proposed to overcome these challenges. RF measurements can be utilized for positioning in multiple ways resulting in time-based, angle-based and fingerprinting-based methods. Different methods, however, impose different implementation requirements to the system, and may perform differently in terms of accuracy for a given setting. In this paper, we use artificial neural networks (ANNs) to realize time-of-arrival (ToA)-based and channel impulse response (CIR) fingerprinting-based positioning. We compare their performance for different indoor environments based on real-world ultra-wideband (UWB) measurements. We first show that using ML techniques helps to improve the estimation accuracy compared to conventional techniques for time-based positioning. When comparing time-based and fingerprinting schemes using ANNs, we show that the favorable method in terms of positioning accuracy is different for different environments, where the accuracy is affected not only by the radio propagation conditions but also on the density and distribution of reference user locations used for fingerprinting.