Next Generation Sequencing Outperforms Cultivation-Based Methods for Detection of Bacterial Genera in Bile After Liver Transplantation

Background and aims: Bacterial cholangitis is a common complication in patients with ischemic type biliary lesions and/or anastomotic strictures after liver transplantation (LTX). Patients frequently need antibiotics and endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERC) to improve the bile flow. Antibiotic treatment is based on findings in standard microbiological cultivation (SMC) of bile. However, the cultivation techniques are limited to a subset of bacteria easy-to-cultivate. Therefore, the aim of our study was to evaluate the value of next generation sequencing as an additional diagnostic tool to SMC in ischemic type biliary lesions and/or anastomotic strictures. Methods: We sequenced the V1-V2 region of the 16S rRNA gene in 242 stored bile samples in patients after LTX and compared the results with findings of SMC. SMC was performed in n = 135 (56%) fresh bile samples in addition to NGS. SMC was part of the clinical routine in these patients. Results: NGS detected bacterial genera in bile samples more often than SMC (P = 5.42 x 10(-74)). SMC showed insufficient discovery of bacterial genera compared to NGS with better performance in patients receiving antibiotics prior to ERC. SMC missed many bacterial genera detected by NGS. Conclusions: NGS was more sensitive in detecting bacteria in bile than SMC, no clinical parameters could be used to improve discovery rates in SMC and many genera were missed by SMC. Therefore, NGS should be used in a combined approach with SMC for improved diagnostics to achieve more specific and targeted antibiotic treatments.