Vacuum Phenomenon in the Lumbar Spine: Pilot Study for Accuracy of Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Objectives: Vacuum phenomenon (VP) is defined as air within a joint. Many pathologies are associated with VP, mainly degenerative disease and trauma. Although patients with intradiscal gas may be asymptomatic, it promotes disc degeneration and can eventually become painful. VP is suspected to be an indicator of segmental mobility, helping in determining the extent of spinal fusion in a preoperative setting. This could make the detection of VP useful on routine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the lower spine. We determined the accuracy of MRI in detecting intradiscal gas through a retrospective observational study. Materials and methods: The study population consists of 37 consecutive patients with low back pain who were scheduled for treatment with spinal infiltrations and received a computed tomography and MRI scan within a maximum time interval of 3 months. Spin echo (SE) T1 and T2 and gradient echo (GE) T1 sequences were analyzed. All scans were randomly coded and evaluated by two observers: an experienced neuroradiologist and a radiology resident for the presence of VP. Results: GE-imaging revealed a high accuracy with a sensitivity of 89.3%-92% and a specificity of 89.7-95.3% between both observers. In comparison to a sensitivity of 31.5%-76.3% for T1- and 8.5%-86.4% for T2-imaging and a specificity of 95%-100% for T1- and 63.7%-100% for T2-imaging with respective accuracy of 68.1%-85.7% and 54.6%-68.9%. We notice a moderate interobserver variability for the T1 (kappa = 0.462) weighted imaging, no agreement for T2 (kappa = 0.057) weighted imaging, and almost perfect interobserver variability for the GE sequence (kappa = 0.889). Conclusion: The presence of VP in degenerative disc disease is a sign of segmental instability which is important for planning spinal fusion surgery. Our study showed that VP can be detected on MRI of the lumbar spine with high accuracy and almost perfect interobserver agreement by adding GE sequences to the scanning protocol.