Future forests and biodiversity: Effects of Douglas fir introduction into temperate beech forests on plant diversity

Introduction of drought-tolerant exotic tree species is seen as an important adaptation measure of forest management to climate change in Central Europe. Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) is particularly favored in this context, because it is adapted to summer droughts due to the climate in its natural distribution range in temperate western North America and it is also fast-growing and the wood is readily marketable. In Germany, there are plans to grow Douglas fir on a large scale in mixed forests with other tree species on acidic soils. Potential ecological consequences have not yet been sufficiently scrutinized. Here, we analyze effects of Douglas fir introduction into forests of European beech (Fagus sylvatica), which would naturally predominate Central Europe's forests. We analyzed vascular plant diversity and species composition of the ground vegetation in a gradient with increasing Douglas fir canopy fraction that ranged from pure beech (0% Douglas fir) via mixed stands (25%, 50%, 75% Douglas fir) to pure (100%) Douglas fir forest. Species richness, Shannon diversity, and Simpson diversity increased with increasing Douglas fir canopy fraction. However, this increase was primarily driven by an increase of nitrogen-tolerant disturbance indicators, whereas the share of forest species that were predominant in pure beech forests decreased. Beech forest species declined gradually with increasing Douglas fir canopy fraction, but these declining species were fewer than the number of species increasing due to Douglas fir introduction. Cover of similar to 30% of species remained constant when Douglas fir was introduced. Strong changes in the ground vegetation were observed at Douglas fir canopy fractions > 40 - 50% and the original character of the ground vegetation was completely lost beyond a threshold of 75%. Therefore, we discourage from high Douglas fir proportions beyond these thresholds in production forests and from any introduction of Douglas fir where nature conservation is a priority.