From Stock Selection to Portfolio Alpha Generation: The Role of Fundamental Analysis

In this roundtable sponsored by Columbia Business School's Center for Excellence in Accounting Research and Security Analysis, a group of successful investors discuss their approaches and methods. A common saying among financial economists is that stock prices are set not by the average investor, but at the margin by the most sophisticated and influential investors. The intent of this roundtable is to furnish a portrait of such marginal investors, one that turns out to be quite different from the quarterly earnings-driven, momentum traders often depicted by the media and deplored by corporate executives. In response to the common charge of short termism leveled by corporate managers, most of the investors at the table claimed to take large, multi-year positions in companies they believed to be well-managed, but temporarily undervalued. Instead of being attracted to earnings momentum, and rather than simply capitalizing current earnings at industry-wide multiples to arrive at price targets, the analysis of these investors begins with a deep dive into a company's financials, which is often reinforced by primary research - visits with management, customers, suppliers. The aim of such research is to identify, well before the broad market does, companies that promise to earn consistently high and sustainable returns on invested capital.