An integrated proximal-distal radiocarbon dating approach provides improved age constraints for a key Holocene tephra isochron

Volcanic ash (tephra) horizons are an essential tool for the spatial and temporal correlation of many natural archives. However, tephrochronology is accompanied by age uncertainties that often limit its capacity to effectively constrain age models. This is particularly problematic for paleoseismology in complex tectonic settings such as New Zealand, where the accuracy and precision of earthquake ages is important for interpreting past fault interactions and earthquake sequences. We use the widespread Waimihia tephra, erupted at ∼3.4 ka from Taupō volcano, as a case study for generating improved age constraints for Holocene tephra isochrons. Our dating strategy minimizes uncertainties by (i) conducting detailed assessments to identify the most reliable dateable material, (ii) using precise AMS dating techniques, and (iii) constructing Bayesian age models. By applying consistent procedures to date tephra deposits at proximal, onshore distal and offshore distal locations, we also facilitate the detection of any geographic radiocarbon bias. Based on high agreement between the independently derived tephra ages from each location, we demonstrate no offsets in radiocarbon results between proximal and distal deposits, precluding bias from near-vent magmatic degassing. Our integrated age model exploits the benefits of each individual dating approach and uses the full suite of 42 new radiocarbon dates to yield an age of 3574–3478 cal yr BP (highest 95% range) for the Waimihia eruption. Compared to previous estimates, this older and more precise age has implications for refining existing paleoearthquake correlations and other chronologies that rely on the Waimihia isochron to provide age control. We recommend applying this multi-location approach to existing tephrochronologies where possible, to achieve more accurate and precise eruption age estimates that allow for the detection of radiocarbon bias.