Fiends and Fools: A Narrative Review and Neo-socioanalytic Perspective on Personality and Insider Threats

Insider threats represent a serious threat to organizations but are considered to be difficult to predict and prevent. Although a growing body of research has examined personological antecedents to insider threats, this literature lacks a unifying theoretical perspective connecting the characteristics that have been researched. In addition to cataloging the personality factors that have been associated with insider threat behaviors, this review also proposes neo-socioanalytic theory as a useful framework for organizing these factors and for distinguishing insider threats from counterproductive work behaviors and workplace accidents. The majority of risk and protective factors related to insider threats were shared for both malicious and non-malicious insider threat behaviors. However, the prior literature strongly suggests that malicious threats are motivated by selfishness and the rationalization of immoral behavior, while non-malicious threats are better understood as being associated with maladjustment and curiosity.