Identification of Origin for Spinal Metastases from MR Images: Comparison Between Radiomics and Deep Learning Methods

-OBJECTIVE: To determine whether spinal metastatic le-sions originated from lung cancer or from other cancers based on spinal contrast-enhanced T1 (CET1) magnetic resonance (MR) images analyzed using radiomics (RAD) and deep learning (DL) methods. -METHODS: We recruited and retrospectively reviewed 173 patients diagnosed with spinal metastases at two different centers between July 2018 and June 2021. Of these, 68 involved lung cancer and 105 were other types of cancer. They were assigned to an internal cohort of 149 patients, randomly divided into a training set and a vali-dation set, and to an external cohort of 24 patients. All patients underwent CET1-MR imaging before surgery or biopsy. We developed two predictive algorithms: a DL model and a RAD model. We compared performance be-tween models, and against human radiological assess-ment, via accuracy (ACC) and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analyses. Furthermore, we analyzed the correlation between RAD and DL features. -RESULTS: The DL model outperformed RAD model across the board, with ACC/ area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) values of 0.93/0.94 (DL) versus 0.84/0.93 (RAD) when applied to the training set from the internal cohort, 0.74/0.76 versus 0.72/0.75 when applied to the validation set, and 0.72/0.76 versus 0.69/0.72 when applied to the external test cohort. For the validation set, it also outperformed expert radiological assessment (ACC: 0.65, AUC: 0.68). We only found weak correlations between DL and RAD features.- CONCLUSION: The DL algorithm successfully identified the origin of spinal metastases from pre-operative CET1- MR images, outperforming both RAD models and expert assessment by trained radiologists.