Are We Overoperating on Isolated Orbital Floor Fractures?

Background: Orbital floor fracture defect size and inferior rectus (IR) rounding index are currently accepted indications for surgery to prevent late enophthalmos. The authors analyzed the positive predictive value (PPV) of these indications.Methods: Twenty-eight patients with orbital floor fractures presenting without enophthalmos underwent Hertel exophthalmometry at presentation and at weeks 1, 2, 3, 6, 13, 26, and 52 or more after injury. Orbital defect size and IR rounding index were measured from computed tomographic scans, and PPVs of defects of 1.5 to 2 cm(2) or larger and IR rounding index of 1 or higher for enophthalmos (=2 mm) were calculated.Results: Nineteen patients had isolated orbital floor fractures (group A), three had noncontinuous orbital floor and medial wall fractures (group B), and six had continuous orbital floor with medial wall fractures (group C). Mean follow-up time was 440 days. Of all patients, 20 had a defect size of 1.5 cm(2) or larger, 12 had a defect of 2.0 cm(2) or larger, and 13 had an IR rounding index of 1 or higher. Of the 28 patients, only one from group A and two from group C developed enophthalmos of 2 mm only. The PPVs of orbital floor defect size of 1.5 cm(2) or larger and 2 cm(2) or larger (groups A and B only) for late enophthalmos were 6.7% and 0%, respectively. The PPV of IR rounding index of 1 or higher for late enophthalmos (all groups) was 0%.Conclusions: For patients with orbital floor fractures presenting without enophthalmos, defects of 1.5 cm(2) or larger and 2 cm(2) or larger, and IR rounding index of 1 or higher, are weakly predictive of late enophthalmos. Furthermore, patients who do not develop enophthalmos within 3 weeks of injury are unlikely to develop significant (>2 mm) late enophthalmos.CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Risk, III.