A systematic review of the clinical features of pneumonia in children aged 5-9 years: Implications for guidelines and research.

Background:Childhood pneumonia presents a large global burden, though most data and guidelines focus on children less than 5 years old. Less information is available about the clinical presentation of pneumonia in children 5-9 years of age. Appropriate diagnostic and treatment algorithms may differ from those applied to younger children. This systematic literature review aimed to identify clinical features of pneumonia in children aged 5-9 years, with a focus on delineation from other age groups and comparison with existing WHO guidance for pneumonia in children less than 5 years old. Methods:We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE and PubMed databases for publications that described clinical features of pneumonia in children 5-9 years old, from any country with no date restriction in English. The quality of included studies was evaluated using a modified Effective Public Health Project Practice (EPHPP) tool. Data relating to research context, study type, clinical features of pneumonia and comparisons with children less than 5 years old were extracted. For each clinical feature of pneumonia, we described mean percentage (95% confidence interval) of participants with this finding in terms of aetiology (all cause vs Mycoplasma pneumoniae), and method of diagnosis (radiological vs clinical). Results:We included 15 publications, eight addressing all-cause pneumonia and seven addressing Mycoplasma pneumoniae. Cough and fever were common in children aged 5-9 years with pneumonia. Tachypnoea was documented in around half of patients. Dyspnoea/difficulty breathing and chest indrawing were present in approximately half of all-cause pneumonia cases, with no data on indrawing in the outpatient setting. Chest and abdominal pain were documented in around one third of cases of all-cause pneumonia, based on limited numbers. In addition to markers of pneumonia severity used in children <5 years, pallor has been identified as being associated with poorer outcomes alongside comorbidities and nutritional status. Conclusions:Quality research exploring clinical features of pneumonia, treatment and outcomes in children aged 5-9 years using consistent inclusion criteria, definitions of features and age ranges are urgently needed to better inform practice and guidelines. Based on limited data fever and cough are common in this age group, but tachypnoea cannot be relied on for diagnosis. While waiting for better evidence, broader attention to features such as chest and abdominal pain, the role of chest radiographs for diagnosis in the absence of symptoms such as tachypnoea, and risk factors which may influence patient disposition (chest indrawing, pallor, nutritional status) warrant consideration by clinicians. Protocol registration:PROSPERO: CRD42020213837.