History of Preeclampsia in Patients Undergoing a Kidney Biopsy: A Biphasic, Multiple-Hit Pathogenic Hypothesis

Introduction: It is not fully elucidated whether preeclampsia (PE) is a marker or a cause of chronic kidney disease (CKD). To test the hypothesis of a biphasic relationship between PE and CKD, we assessed PE prevalence in women who underwent a kidney biopsy. Methods: This retrospective, observational study recruited patients who underwent a kidney biopsy after delivery in 2014 to 2019 in 3 Italian Centers (Cagliari, Bari, Messina); low-risk pregnancies observed in Cagliari served as controls. A history of PE was assessed on the clinical charts and by phone interview. Results: In the biopsy cohort (379 pregnancies, 205 patients; 38 PE in 32 patients), kidney biopsy shows clustering in the first 5 years after PE (11 of 32). Pre-existing CKD was detected in 8 of 11 of these cases. Focal-segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) and complex lesions were found in 12 of 32 biopsies. The odds ratio (OR) of having had a PE episode, compared with 561 low-risk pregnancies, was 10.071 (95% CI: 4.859-20.875; P < 0.001); multiparity maintained a protective effect (OR: 0.208). The delivery-to-biopsy time was significantly shorter in women with PE, both considering the first or the last PE versus the first or last delivery in patients with or without PE episodes. The characteristics of PE did not differ as compared with low-risk controls. Conclusion: Within the limitation of the retrospective design, our study, quantifying the association between needing a kidney biopsy and history of PE, suggests a biphasic pattern, with a peak in the first 5 years after delivery (probably due to pre-existing diseases) and a later increase, suggesting that PE may have later played as one hit in a multiple-hit pathogenesis.