Labeling Defective T*

This paper proposes a new analysis of so-called 'defective T' (a postulate originally discussed in Chomsky 2000, 2001) and seeks a label-based theoretical explanation of phenomena associated with the distribution of subjects in infinitival clauses. I argue that we do not need to postulate 'defective T' as an element of the lexicon. Following Chomsky's (2013, 2015) labeling approach, which investigates only finite clauses, I argue here that the subject of infinitive-to is pair-merged structure and the associated predicate forms an {XP, YP} structure, which is unlabelable. To attain labeling, the subject position ([spec, TP]) in the infinitival clause moves out and the label of the resulting structure is the amalgam , which has no visible Spec (violating EPP). As a consequence, we eliminate the Merge-over-Move principle.