Clinical insignificance of [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid non-specific bone lesions: a retrospective evaluation

Purpose [F-18]PSMA-1007 offers advantages of low urinary tracer excretion and theoretical improved spatial resolution for imaging prostate cancer. However, non-specific bone lesions (NSBLs), defined as mild to moderate focal bone uptake without a typical morphological correlate on CT, are a common finding on [F-18]PSMA-1007 PET/CT. The purpose of this study was to investigate the clinical outcomes of patients with [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid NSBLs, to determine whether patients with NSBLs represent a higher risk clinical cohort, and to determine whether SUVmax can be used as a classifier of bone metastasis. Methods A retrospective audit of 214 men with prostate cancer was performed to investigate the clinical outcomes of [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid NSBLs according to defined criteria. We also compared the serum PSA, Gleason score, and uptake time of patients with [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid NSBLs to patients without [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid bone lesions. Finally, we analysed an SUVmax threshold to identify bone metastases using ROC curve analysis. Results Ninety-four of 214 patients (43.9%) demonstrated at least one NSBL. No [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid NSBLs met criteria for a likely malignant or definitely malignant lesion after a median 15.8-month follow-up interval (11.9% definitely benign, 50.3% likely benign, and 37.7% equivocal). There were no statistically significant differences in serum PSA, Gleason score, and uptake time between patients with [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid NSBLs and those without [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid bone lesions. All NSBLs with adequate follow-up had SUVmax <= 11.1. The value of the highest SUVmax distinguished between NSBLs and definite prostate cancer bone metastases, whereby an SUVmax threshold of >= 7.2 maximized the Youden's index. Conclusion [F-18]PSMA-1007 avid NSBLs rarely represent prostate cancer bone metastases. When identified in the absence of definite metastatic disease elsewhere, it is appropriate to classify those with SUVmax < 7.2 as likely benign. NSBLs with SUVmax 7.2-11.1 may be classified as equivocal or metastatic, with patient clinical risk factors, scan appearance, and potential management implications used to guide interpretation.