Coma Influence On Manifest Astigmatism In Coma-Dominant Irregular Corneal Optics

PURPOSE: To evaluate the influence of coma on manifest refractive cylinder (MRC) in eyes with coma-dominated corneal optics and suggest alternative guidelines for surgical planning of astigmatism correction in topography-guided ablation and toric intraocular lens (IOL) exchange surgery.METHODS: Twelve eyes with coma-dominant corneal optics and low lenticular astigmatism were selected. The astigmatism remaining after subtraction of total corneal astigmatism (TCA) and lenticular astigmatism from MRC, termed discrepant astigmatism, was calculated and correlated to corneal coma at the anterior surface. Refractive and topography data were then used to simulate topography-guided refractive surgery (topography-guided group) in 7 eyes and lenticular exchange surgery with toric intraocular lens (IOL) implantation (toric IOL group) in 5 eyes. The estimated postoperative MRC after correction of TCA or MRC for each group was compared.RESULTS: The axis and amplitude of discrepant astigmatism correlated strongly with the axis and amplitude of coma. In the topography-guided group, where topography-guided ablation eliminated corneal higher order aberrations (HOAs), TCA-based correction led to less estimated postoperative manifest astigmatism than MRC-based correction. In the toric IOL group, where removal of the crystalline lens did not affect corneal HOAs, MRC-based correction via toric IOL implantation led to less estimated postoperative astigmatism than TCA-based correction.CONCLUSIONS: Discrepant astigmatism in eyes with comadominant corneal optics correlates with coma. In such eyes, treating TCA, along with corneal HOAs, instead of MRC, seems appropriate in topography-guided treatments, whereas treating MRC may be a better choice in lenticular exchange surgery with toric IOL implantation, where corneal HOAs are not treated.