Molecular convergent and parallel evolution among four high-elevation anuran species from the Tibetan region

Background To date, evidence for the relative prevalence or rarity of molecular convergent and parallel evolution is conflicting, and understanding of how these processes contribute to adaptation is limited. We compared four high-elevation anuran species ( Bufo tibetanus , Nanorana parkeri , Rana kukunoris and Scutiger boulengeri ) from the Tibetan region, and examined convergent and parallel amino acid substitutions between them and how they may have contributed to high-elevation adaptation. Results Genomic data of the four high-elevation species and eight of their low-elevation close relatives were gathered. A total of 1098 orthologs shared by all species were identified. We first conducted pairwise comparisons using Zhang and Kumar’s test. Then, the R conv index was calculated and convergence/divergence correlation plotting was conducted. Furthermore, genes under positive selection and with elevated evolutionary rate were examined. We detected a large number of amino acid sites with convergent or parallel substitutions. Several pairs of high-elevation species, in particular, R. kukunoris vs N. parkeri and B. tibetanus vs S. boulengeri , had excessive amounts of convergent substitutions compared to neutral expectation. Nevertheless, these sites were mostly concentrated in a small number of genes (3–32), and no genome-wide convergence was detected. Furthermore, the majority of these convergent genes were neither under detectable positive selection nor had elevated evolutionary rates, although functional prediction analysis suggested some of the convergent genes could potentially contribute to high-elevation adaptation. Conclusions There is a substantial amount of convergent evolution at the amino-acid level among high-elevation amphibians, although these sites are concentrated in a few genes, not widespread across the genomes. This may attribute to the fact that all the target species are from the same environment. The relative prevalence of convergent substitutions among high-elevation amphibians provides an excellent opportunity for further study of molecular convergent evolution.