Learn the Switches: Evolving FPGA NoCs with Stall-Free and Backpressure Based Routers

We can overcome the pessimism in worst-case routing latency analysis of timing-predictable Network-on-Chip (NoC) workloads by single digit factors through the use of a hybrid FPGA-optimized NoC. Timing-predictable FPGA-optimized NoCs such as HopliteBuf integrate stall-free FIFOs that are sized using offline, static analysis of a user-supplied flow pattern and rates. For certain bursty traffic and flow configurations, the static analysis delivers very large, sometimes infeasible, FIFO size bounds and large worst-case latency bounds. Alternatively, backpressure-based NoCs such as HopliteBP can operate with lower latencies for certain bursty flows. However, they suffer from severe pessimism in the analysis due to the effect of pipelining of packets and interleaving of flows at switch ports. As we show in this paper, a hybrid FPGA NoC that seamlessly composes both design styles on a per-switch basis, delivers the best of both worlds with improved feasibility (bounded operation), and tighter latency bounds. We select the NoC switch configuration though a novel evolutionary algorithm based on Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE). For synthetic (RANDOM, LOCAL) and real world (SpMV, Graph) workloads, we demonstrate ≈2– 3× improvements in feasibility, ≈1–6.8× in worst-case latency while only requiring LUT cost ≈1–1.5× larger than the cheapest HopliteBuf solution. We also deploy and verify our NoC (PL) and MLE framework (PS) on a Pynq-Z1 to adapt and reconfigure NoC switches dynamically.