Differences in Ice Cloud Optical Depth from CALIPSO and Ground-Based Raman Lidar at the ARM SGP and TWP Sites

Ice cloud column optical depths from the Cloud-Aerosol Lidar and Infrared Pathfinder Satellite Observations (CALIPSO) satellite and ground-based Raman lidars (RLs) at the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) Southern Great Plains (SGP) and Tropical Western Pacific (TWP) sites are compared for 8 and 4years, respectively. The cloudy mean ice cloud column optical depths from CALIPSO Version 4 data product with a horizontal resolution of 5km are 78% (63%) larger than those from the RLs with a resolution of 10min/30 m at SGP (TWP) for collocated transparent profiles. The main difference at SGP is caused by the lidar ratio that for CALIPSO is related to its treatment of the multiple scattering factor. The main difference at TWP is caused by the averaging resolution. Large differences in the optical depth distribution between the CALIPSO and RL are found for small optical depths at both sites, which are due to optically very thin clouds only detectable by the RLs. The differences in ice cloud column optical depth distributions and their mean values between the CALIPSO and RL can largely be reconciled over both sites after accounting for the averaging resolutions, lidar ratios along with the CALIPSO multiple scattering factor treatment, sensitivity to optically very thin ice clouds, and definition of transparent profiles. This work also examines in detail the lidar ratios that are directly observed by the RLs, which does not support the temperature-dependent parameterizations of ice cloud lidar ratio and multiple scattering factor used in CALIPSO's Version 4 data product.